Pico-8 vs. MakeCode Arcade

PICO-8 is a fantasy console that provides an environment for creating, sharing, and playing small digital games and programs. PICO-8 deliberately embraces limitations to foster creativity and learning. Hearing about this, I have thought about whether to incorporate PICO-8 in my classes, or even replace MakeCode Arcade with it. So I thought I would have Perplexity generate a comparison.

This comparison evaluates both platforms specifically for educators teaching 9th-grade students who may use Chromebooks, providing detailed analysis of each platform’s strengths and limitations for classroom implementation.

Note that even though Perplexity is good at referring to sources, the actual URLs it provides are sometimes broken. I assume that’s because it will partially hallucinate a completed URL if it has incomplete information. Also, the details in the comparisons sometimes lack context (like, whether you’re talking about the paid vs. free version of something).

All that said, this has helped me get a little bit of a handle on the differences between a platform I already use and what Pico-8 has to offer.

Technical Infrastructure & Accessibility

Category	PICO-8	Microsoft MakeCode Arcade
Chromebook Compatibility	Education Edition: Free browser version works perfectly on Chromebooks123. Full Version: Requires Linux mode (often disabled for student accounts)45	Native browser support - runs seamlessly on all Chromebooks without any setup678
Installation Requirements	Education Edition: None (browser-based). Full version: $15 with site-wide educational license29	None - completely web-based and free6108
Offline Capability	Education Edition: Limited offline work. Full version: Complete offline functionality	Requires internet connection for most features6
Hardware Requirements	Minimal (~700MHz CPU)2	Any device with web browser and keyboard67
Account Management	Education Edition: No accounts needed. Full version: Optional cloud saves12	Optional Microsoft account for cloud saves and persistent sharing11

Educational Licensing \& Cost

Category	PICO-8	Microsoft MakeCode Arcade
Initial Cost	$15 for full version includes site-wide educational license29	Completely free6108
Student Take-Home	$3 per student for take-home licenses29	Free for all students on personal devices8
Administrative Burden	Requires educator registration for bulk licenses2	No registration or licensing required8
Budget Impact	Medium: ~$15-500 depending on take-home needs	None

Programming Languages \& Learning Progression

Category	PICO-8	Microsoft MakeCode Arcade
Primary Language	Lua (P8 variant) - text-based from start1213	Visual blocks → JavaScript/TypeScript → Python6101415
Learning Curve	Steeper initial curve but builds strong programming fundamentals13	Gentler progression from visual to text-based coding6108
9th Grade Appropriateness	May require more teacher programming knowledge. Suitable for students ready for text-based coding	Ideal scaffolding from visual blocks to professional languages168
Transition to Professional Tools	Direct path to Lua, game engines, low-level programming	Clear progression to JavaScript, Python, TypeScript - highly marketable skills1015
Debugging \& Error Handling	Command-line interface, requires understanding of error messages	Visual error highlighting, user-friendly error messages15

Curriculum \& Educational Resources

Category	PICO-8	Microsoft MakeCode Arcade
Official Curriculum	No official curriculum, community-driven resources	Full academic year AP Computer Science Principles curriculum168
Lesson Plans	Community tutorials, requires teacher adaptation	Structured lessons, skillmaps, tutorials with assessments161718
Teacher Training	Self-directed learning, community support	Professional development, Microsoft Learn courses, Arcade-Con conferences178
Assessment Tools	Manual assessment, community rubrics	Built-in assessment features, Microsoft integration1611
Classroom Management	Basic sharing through PNG files or BBS uploads13	Google Classroom/Teams integration, assignment creation1911

Creative Constraints \& Technical Specifications

Category	PICO-8	Microsoft MakeCode Arcade
Display Resolution	128×128 pixels, 16 colors	160×120 pixels, 16 colors (customizable palettes)610
Code Limitations	8,192 tokens maximum	No explicit code limits but performance constraints on large projects2021
Asset Creation	Integrated sprite/map/sound editors	Integrated editors with more modern UI/UX615
Educational Value of Constraints	Extremely focused environment teaches fundamentals within strict limits	More flexible while maintaining retro aesthetic for engagement108
Project Scope	Encourages small, polished games due to strict constraints	Allows for larger, more complex projects2221

Community \& Sharing

Category	PICO-8	Microsoft MakeCode Arcade
Game Distribution	PNG files (unique “cartridge” format), BBS community13	URL sharing, persistent links, multiplayer hosting2311
Community Size	Smaller but highly dedicated retro game development community24	Large educational community with Microsoft backing178
Student Showcase	Lexaloffle BBS for public sharing1	Multiple sharing options including social media, LMS integration11
Multiplayer Support	Local multiplayer only	Online multiplayer up to 4 players232526
Privacy \& Safety	Community moderation on BBS	Educational-focused with privacy controls8

Performance \& Technical Limitations

Category	PICO-8	Microsoft MakeCode Arcade
Large Project Performance	Handles large projects well within constraints	Performance issues with very large projects, workspace slowdown2021
Stability	Very stable platform, minimal bugs	Occasional asset corruption, block interaction issues2728
Feature Completeness	Mature, feature-complete platform	Active development but some advanced features missing2221
Hardware Deployment	Requires specific PICO-8 compatible devices	Multiple hardware options, DIY-friendly2930

Teacher Preparation \& Support

Category	PICO-8	Microsoft MakeCode Arcade
Programming Background Required	Moderate - teachers should understand basic programming concepts	Minimal - designed for non-CS teachers831
Time Investment	Significant upfront learning investment	Lower barrier to entry with extensive support materials8
Troubleshooting Complexity	Requires understanding of Lua debugging	Visual debugging tools, extensive error documentation1528
Professional Development	Community-driven, self-directed	Formal PD programs, conferences, Microsoft certification paths178

9th Grade Specific Considerations

Category	PICO-8	Microsoft MakeCode Arcade
Age Appropriateness	May be too advanced for struggling students, excellent for motivated learners	Appropriate scaffold for diverse skill levels in typical 9th grade classroom168
Engagement Level	High for students interested in retro gaming and authentic programming	High initial engagement with blocks, maintains interest through progression818
Differentiation	Limited built-in differentiation options	Multiple entry points and complexity levels616
College Prep Value	Strong foundation in programming concepts	Direct preparation for AP CS Principles, industry-standard languages168
Career Readiness	Builds fundamental programming thinking	Teaches current industry tools and practices8

Classroom Management Considerations

Category	PICO-8	Microsoft MakeCode Arcade
Project Recovery	Manual backup required, some risk of work loss	Cloud saves available, version control features being developed28
Collaboration Features	Limited collaborative features	Multi-player development, easy sharing and remixing2311
Assessment Integration	Manual grading, portfolio-based assessment	LMS integration, automated sharing to gradebooks1611
Differentiated Instruction	Requires significant teacher customization	Built-in scaffolding and multiple difficulty levels616

Long-term Educational Value

Category	PICO-8	Microsoft MakeCode Arcade
Skill Transferability	Strong programming fundamentals, constraint-based thinking	Industry-standard languages, modern development practices108
Advanced Learning Pathways	Path to professional game development, system programming	Clear progression to web development, data science, professional programming168
Community Longevity	Stable independent platform	Backed by Microsoft with ongoing development and support8
Industry Relevance	Niche but valuable constraint-based design thinking	High relevance to current tech industry needs8

Critical Decision Factors for 9th Grade Educators:

1. If your priority is immediate Chromebook deployment without IT complications: MakeCode Arcade is clearly superior
2. If you want to teach fundamental programming concepts with minimal visual distractions: PICO-8 may be more effective
3. If you need extensive curriculum support and aren’t confident in programming: MakeCode Arcade provides comprehensive educational scaffolding
4. If budget is a significant constraint: MakeCode Arcade’s free model is advantageous
5. If you want students to transition to industry-standard languages: MakeCode Arcade provides clearer pathways to JavaScript/Python/TypeScript

Both platforms can create excellent learning experiences, but MakeCode Arcade appears more suitable for typical 9th-grade classroom environments, particularly those with Chromebooks and teachers who need substantial curriculum support.

⁂

1. https://www.lexaloffle.com/bbs/?tid=47278 ↩ ↩² ↩³ ↩⁴ ↩⁵

2. https://www.lexaloffle.com/pico-8.php?page=schools ↩ ↩² ↩³ ↩⁴ ↩⁵ ↩⁶ ↩⁷

3. https://www.lexaloffle.com/bbs/?tid=47278\&rut=d2be564eb7c81b612d2de7a51dd722f3c3ec80ee82a1878360d577b8e7e69db6 ↩ ↩² ↩³

4. https://www.reddit.com/r/pico8/comments/1jsxho6/pico8_on_kids_chromebook/ ↩

5. https://www.lexaloffle.com/bbs/?pid=31328 ↩

6. https://arcade.makecode.com/ide-tour ↩ ↩² ↩³ ↩⁴ ↩⁵ ↩⁶ ↩⁷ ↩⁸ ↩⁹ ↩¹⁰ ↩¹¹

7. https://learn.adafruit.com/makecode-arcade-with-raspberry-pi-zero/what-is-makecode-arcade ↩ ↩²

8. https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/education/blog/2022/11/developing-interest-in-computer-science-with-microsoft-makecode/ ↩ ↩² ↩³ ↩⁴ ↩⁵ ↩⁶ ↩⁷ ↩⁸ ↩⁹ ↩¹⁰ ↩¹¹ ↩¹² ↩¹³ ↩¹⁴ ↩¹⁵ ↩¹⁶ ↩¹⁷ ↩¹⁸ ↩¹⁹ ↩²⁰ ↩²¹ ↩²² ↩²³

9. https://www.lexaloffle.com/bbs/?pid=28885 ↩ ↩² ↩³

10. https://makecode.com/blog/arcade/01-18-2019 ↩ ↩² ↩³ ↩⁴ ↩⁵ ↩⁶ ↩⁷ ↩⁸

11. https://arcade.makecode.com/share ↩ ↩² ↩³ ↩⁴ ↩⁵ ↩⁶ ↩⁷

12. https://fr.scribd.com/document/827853892/Plan-detaille-pour-apprendre-Lua-avec-PICO-8 ↩

13. https://funtech.co.uk/latest/is-lua-hard-to-learn ↩ ↩²

14. https://arcade.makecode.com/python ↩

15. https://makecode.com/blog/arcade/update-july-2020 ↩ ↩² ↩³ ↩⁴ ↩⁵

16. https://www.csforall.org/members/microsoft_makecode/curriculum/introduction_to_computer_science_with_microsoft_makecode_arcade/ ↩ ↩² ↩³ ↩⁴ ↩⁵ ↩⁶ ↩⁷ ↩⁸ ↩⁹ ↩¹⁰

17. https://forum.makecode.com/t/arcade-con-2025-is-coming/34249 ↩ ↩² ↩³ ↩⁴

18. https://www.tes.com/teaching-resource/makecode-arcade-coding-guide-1-make-your-own-catching-game-13004444 ↩ ↩²

19. https://forum.makecode.com/t/teachers-what-would-you-prefer/10525 ↩

20. https://forum.makecode.com/t/i-m-stepping-away-from-makecode/25809 ↩ ↩²

21. https://forum.makecode.com/t/makecode-arcade-without-the-arcade/24087?page=2 ↩ ↩² ↩³ ↩⁴

22. https://forum.makecode.com/t/features-i-want-in-makecode-arcade/12961 ↩ ↩²

23. https://arcade.makecode.com/multiplayer ↩ ↩² ↩³

24. https://www.lexaloffle.com/bbs/?tid=47691 ↩

25. https://forum.makecode.com/t/makecode-arcade-online-multiplayer/14259 ↩

26. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wDYe3RKGbGI ↩

27. https://forum.makecode.com/t/i-can-t-interact-with-the-blocks-in-my-game/31033 ↩

28. https://forum.makecode.com/t/common-errors/22543 ↩ ↩² ↩³

29. https://arcade.makecode.com/hardware ↩

30. https://github.com/AqeeAqee/Arcade-Pico ↩

31. https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/limitations-microsoft-makecode-middle-school-coding-education-prasad ↩